I think it’s fair to say that nobody saw this kind of start from the Boston Red Sox coming.
Following an October where the Sox bulldozed the rest of Major League Baseball en route to their fourth World Series victory in the 21st Century, they’ve had a fairly rough start to their title defense campaign this year. The story so far goes a little something like this:
- They open the season with an eleven-game road trip (!) down the west coast, picking up a win apiece against the Seattle Mariners, Oakland Athletics and Arizona Diamondbacks…
- Followed by a 3-3 homestand where they split series against the Toronto Blue Jays and Baltimore Orioles…
- And as recently as last night, got clocked by the New York Yankees in two games.
And all the while, very little, if anything at all, seems to have clicked; the starting pitching has been getting lit up like Christmas trees more often than not, the defense has been sloppy, and the bats have been a far cry from last year’s juggernaut lineup. The only saving grace for the Red Sox has been, at least for the most part, their bullpen. Of course, that’s not saying much when they don’t have a lead to protect in the first place.
As of now, the Red Sox find themselves in the bottom half of most major statistical categories, including a garish second-to-last in team ERA at 6.01…only a few ticks ahead of the Orioles. It’s a concerning prospect, considering this is a rotation that more or less mowed down the Yankees, Houston Astros and Los Angeles Dodgers back in October. But aside from excellent recent outings by David Price (seven shutout innings against the Orioles…beggars can’t be choosers) and Nathan Eovaldi (six innings of one-run ball against the Yankees), everyone else has been 50 flavors of godawful. When it comes to ace Chris Sale, it’s especially frustrating given that he tends to start off fine before unraveling not long after.
(It also doesn’t help that he inked a fresh new contract as Spring Training was winding down.)
And the bats…well, again, the difference between last year and this year is poles apart, with the team sitting in 20th place for batting average as opposed to being the best in that category last season. JD Martinez and Mitch Moreland have been carrying the bulk of the freight for the offense, with occasional contributions by reigning AL MVP Mookie Betts and Christian Vazquez. Apart from those four, and a walkoff hit by Rafael Devers against the Jays, the offense hasn’t made as much noise.
Put it all together, and this is where the Sox are at as of this post: 6-13, last in the American League East, and looking up at their next opponents, the Tampa Bay Rays.
On paper, this shouldn’t be happening. Apart from Joe Kelly taking his talents to the Los Angeles Dodgers following a phenomenal postseason, and Craig Kimbrel remaining in free agency limbo, this is virtually the same team that won it all, top to bottom; Sale, Betts, Price, Martinez, as the saying goes in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, everyone is here. So it begs the question: What’s going on? Why is this Red Sox team floundering when they blew the doors off of everyone last year?
Let’s start by addressing a fairly common complaint: No, the opening roadtrip had nothing to do with it. As annoying as it was to open the new season with a long string of series out west, that’s not Boston’s fault, nor is it necessarily the league’s fault. People like The Sports Hub’s Tony Massarotti have pointed out that Major League Baseball releases every team’s schedule for the next season around August, and typically there’s no clear indicator of who will win the World Series at that point. It’s not like the NFL where the schedules are hashed out and locked in after a champion has been crowned, and I doubt that Rob Manfred and the powers-that-be would change anything around after the World Series.
Sending catcher Sandy Leon down to the minors at the beginning of the season wasn’t the problem, either, and that was all the more apparent in the first game against the Yankees. Maybe Leon could’ve helped mitigate the early issues to an extent, but even then, it’s highly doubtful he would’ve prevented some of the more miserable starts from happening in the first place.
The overall mentality of the team is something that could be split into two parts: Their “Not Turning the Page” motto, and a supposed sense of entitlement and complacency among the players. I will argue that the former might not be the best frame of mind; I get the message and the desire to continue the current chapter in Sox history, but it gives the impression that they’re stuck on last year, and whatever happens this year is moot because of it. That’s not the kind of mentality you should take on if you’re looking to defend a championship; something like the Astros’ “Never Settle” motto from last year would’ve worked better, where that desire to continue this chapter is there, but they’re still moving forward.
That being said, I don’t think there’s any sort of complacency with this team, nor is there any sense of entitlement. Yes, they’ve referred back to last year so many times it’s actually somewhat irritating, but they’ve talked just as much about how much they want to win another World Series, especially during Spring Training. They know what it takes to win a championship, and they also understand that they’re not entitled to any sort of pass for starting off sluggish; maybe that’s what people are getting from how they’ve been playing, but I don’t see any of that, personally.
And then there’s Spring Training. Manager Alex Cora seemed to take things slower than normal this time around, giving the central players less time to get them warmed up and focusing more on the reserves. The laid-back Spring is something that people also seem to be attributing to the horrid start, a sentiment I’m inclined to agree with. However, at the same time, I’m willing to bring up a point that was made by Barstool Sports writer Jared Carrabis following the walkoff loss to the Diamondbacks. To paraphrase, with the knowledge that the Red Sox gave practically everything they had the October before, they had one of two options going into Spring Training: Either go about preparing for the regular season as normal and come out swinging while risking a midseason burnout, or take a slower approach to dodge the dreaded championship hangover and build energy up in the early-going.
(You can find the article in question here: https://www.barstoolsports.com/boston/red-sox-get-walked-off-by-the-dbacks-to-fall-to-2-8-matching-their-worst-start-to-a-season-in-franchise-history)
While it’s still a bit early to decide whether or not it’s the right call, I will say that it seems like a questionable one at the moment. Championship hangover is something no team wants to go through, and unless you’re the Yankees of the late 90’s or the modern-day Golden State Warriors, defending a title is no easy feat. But even at the start of a new season, you want to come into it fully-prepped and ready to go. Yes, it’s a Catch-22 that no team in any sport wants to be in, but that’s just how it goes sometimes.
And don’t get me wrong, I like Alex Cora; he’s a smart manager, and while his bold moves in the World Series may be haunting his players now, they still yielded great results. But it’s hard to be positive about him when his decision to ease his players along has resulted in such a slow, sloppy start.
Should Red Sox fans panic about this team? I’m going to say no… not yet, anyway. As cliché as it might sound, people need to keep in mind that baseball season is a long grind; there’s time to work things out and turn the tables. Talking heads may proclaim that the end is near (if not already here), but I’m willing to stick it out. Having said that, I will concede that the Red Sox need to start righting the ship sooner as opposed to later; if they’re still playing this badly by, let’s say, the beginning of June, then I’ll agree that it’s time to panic.
On that note, if Red Sox fans should feel anything about this team right now…far be it from me to tell others how to feel…it should be annoyance and frustration. Again, this is virtually the same team from last year aside from a couple of departures. There’s no reason for them to be this bad; we KNOW how good they can be. Watching them get in their own way so often is exasperating, and it’s not only hard to point to one specific problem of theirs, but also point out one specific solution; it’s hard to say whether or not it’ll take more than a dugout conniption from Chris Sale to get this team going in the right direction again. I’m not ready to declare the season a bust quite yet, but the Red Sox need to get everything figured out soon, or else this is going to be a long summer.
‘Til we meet again,
Tom